Health Data & GDPR

Health Data & GDPR

What health data is HR allowed to analyze — and what does GDPR prohibit?

Analyzing health data falls under Art. 9 GDPR. For analyses, only fully anonymized data is permitted (e.g., health reports from statutory health insurers). HR may not use individual sick notes for analyses. Note: this guidance reflects German law.

Permitted vs. prohibited data sources in workplace health management

Data sourceStatus under GDPRCorrect use in WHP
Individual sick notes (Arbeitsunfähigkeitsbescheinigungen)Strictly prohibited for HR analyticsStay in the personnel file — for administrative purposes only
Health insurer sick-leave reports (Krankenkassen-Gesundheitsberichte)Legal — provided it is anonymizedAbove a minimum number of insured employees set by each insurer: a compliant basis for the annual plan
Scientifically validated employee surveysLegal — with the right safeguards in placeAnonymous external tool, no IP-address storage, voluntary participation explicitly communicated
Internal sick-leave statistics (aggregated, anonymous)LegalHR may analyze cross-departmental rates — never at the level of individual employees
Diagnoses from medical certificatesStrictly prohibitedDiagnoses do not belong in the HR file — not even 'just for information'

Why is digging deeper into personnel data risky when sick leave rises?

Because Art. 9 GDPR classifies health data as a special category, giving it the highest level of protection under European data protection law. When sick leave rises, management demands immediate explanations. Understandable — but the reflex to dig deeper into personnel data leads straight into a GDPR trap.

An HR manager who unintentionally handles sick-note diagnoses, or produces demographic breakdowns so granular that individuals become identifiable, risks fines of up to €20 million or 4% of global annual turnover — whichever is higher (Art. 83(5) GDPR).

Germany's statutory prevention guideline (GKV-Leitfaden Prävention) provides for a well-founded baseline analysis in the workplace health promotion (WHP) process. This analysis must be privacy-compliant and based on anonymized data. Anyone who misreads this and starts cataloging individual employees' causes of illness jeopardizes not only data protection but also the basis for support from a health insurer.

Which analysis tools are permitted under data protection law?

Health insurer sick-leave reports: Under Section 20b of Book V of the German Social Code (SGB V), statutory health insurers are required to support workplace health promotion (WHP) — including anonymized health reports. These show aggregated absence rates, diagnosis groups (by ICD-10 chapter), and areas of strain without identifying individuals. The catch: to keep a report anonymous, each insurer sets a minimum number of employees insured with it — the Mobil Krankenkasse, for example, requires at least 50. Some insurers offer alternative solutions for smaller companies.

Workplace health surveys: Scientifically validated survey instruments such as COPSOQ (psychological strain), SALSA (resources), or a company-adapted short questionnaire are a strong tool for a baseline analysis. They comply with data protection law under three conditions: (1) full anonymity with no IP-address storage, (2) voluntary participation communicated explicitly before the survey, (3) results analyzed only in aggregate for groups of five or more people.

Aggregated sick-leave rates: HR may calculate cross-departmental absence rates and present them in the steering committee. The limit is identifiability: departments with fewer than 5 people may not be reported separately — this also applies to seemingly harmless combinations like 'Department X in Q3.'

How do you check a survey for data protection before sending it?

Before an employee survey goes out, this quick check is recommended:

Check 1 — Re-identification test: Could demographic questions (department + age + gender) allow individuals to be identified within small groups? Never analyze groups of fewer than 5 people separately.

Check 2 — Voluntariness clause: Does the survey's landing page clearly state that participation is voluntary and that no IP addresses or timestamps are stored?

Check 3 — Purpose-limitation proof: Is it contractually and technically ensured that the data is used exclusively for WHP measure planning and then deleted? Linking the data to performance reviews is a serious GDPR violation.

What to do when managers ask for diagnoses

A real-world scenario: a department head asks in the steering committee meeting why 'everyone in logistics always seems to be sick.' HR feels the pressure to provide concrete answers. The right response isn't to pull individual sick-note data, but to channel the request toward the permitted analysis tools.

In practice: the health working group (AK Gesundheit) commissions a short analysis using aggregated data. If available, the relevant health insurer's sick-leave report is pulled. If not, a voluntary, anonymous flash survey in the department (respecting the minimum group size) can provide initial insights.

What HR can say: 'We're looking at the department's anonymized absence rates and comparing them to last year. We do not look at individual data — that's not permitted under data protection law, and it isn't our goal either. The goal is to understand workload, not the causes of individual illnesses.'

Related measures & topics

Key takeaways

  • Individual sick-note diagnoses are off-limits for analyses by HR — not even “just for information.”.
  • Health insurer sick-leave reports (provided enough employees are insured with one insurer) are a clean, privacy-compliant analysis tool.
  • Surveys require: anonymity, voluntary participation, purpose limitation, and works council involvement.
  • Groups of fewer than 5 people must never be analyzed individually.

Frequently asked questions

May HR track the number of sick days per employee?+

Yes — the raw number of sick days (without diagnosis) may be recorded for administrative reasons, e.g., for BEM monitoring (Section 167 SGB IX requires tracking the 6-week threshold). However, this data may not be used for performance reviews or analysis purposes beyond the BEM trigger.

What health data may the works council view?+

The works council has a general right to information (Section 80 of the Works Constitution Act, BetrVG), but it too has no claim to individual diagnosis data. It can request aggregated absence statistics. In BEM, the works council monitors whether the employer fulfils its obligations (Section 167(2) SGB IX); it is only involved in an individual BEM procedure with the consent of the person concerned.

Do we need works council approval for an employee survey?+

As a rule, yes. Online surveys are technical facilities under Section 87(1) No. 6 BetrVG and are subject to works council co-determination; if the survey serves the risk assessment, Section 87(1) No. 7 BetrVG also applies. Without works council approval, the company risks an injunction. Involving the works council is not an obstacle, though — it typically strengthens employee acceptance of the survey.

Can we conduct a solid baseline analysis without a health insurer report?+

Yes. For companies below the reporting threshold, a combination of aggregated internal sick-leave rates (HR monitoring), site visits by the company physician, and a voluntary flash survey is recommended. Even without an external health insurer report, this combination provides a sound baseline analysis.

Analyze health data — the right way

EasyWHP aggregates absences, BEM triggers, and measures — without HR ever seeing individual diagnosis data.

Sources

Last updated: 2026-06-24. This guide refers to German law (§ 167 SGB IX) and is not legal advice — have your specific case reviewed by a professional.

Read more