
Documenting a BEM Refusal the Right Way
What do I need to do if an employee refuses the BEM meeting?
If an employee declines BEM, the offer for this occasion has been fulfilled — BEM is voluntary under Section 167(2) SGB IX. The employer's obligation turns into a documentation obligation: what matters now is airtight documentation of the offer and refusal, to safeguard a later dismissal in case of a dispute.
BEM Refusal: Process and Risks
| Process Stage | Requirement | Risk if Mishandled | Safeguard |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Invitation | Offer stating purpose, voluntariness, and a data protection notice (Section 167(2) SGB IX, Art. 9 GDPR) — written form strongly recommended | A refusal in response to a flawed invitation does not relieve the employer — in a dismissal, the employer then bears an extended burden of presentation and proof | Uniform invitation template with a GDPR data protection notice |
| The Refusal | Written or verifiably verbal waiver by the employee | Verbal refusals without witnesses are hard to prove in court — BEM is then treated as “never offered” | Digital case log with status 'Employee Refusal' |
| The Filing | Kept separate from the personnel file, accessible only to authorized staff | Incorrect filing = GDPR violation under Art. 9 + loss of evidence | Dedicated BEM folder, accessible only to the BEM team |
| Documenting the Deadline | No statutory deadline; recommended practice: set and document a response period of about 14 days | Missing deadline documentation = employer cannot prove they waited long enough | Calendar flag + written note in the case log |
Is It Permissible for Employees to Decline BEM?
Note: This article describes German employment and data protection law — Section 167 SGB IX (Social Code Book IX) and GDPR — and reflects the German legal framework for occupational reintegration management (BEM). It is not legal advice and does not cover other jurisdictions.
Yes — BEM is voluntary and a refusal is permissible; what matters then is documentation. HR professionals know the scenario well: an employee crosses the critical threshold — unable to work for more than six weeks within one year (German law). The mandatory BEM invitation goes out — and the reply that comes back is a short, wary 'No thanks, not needed.'
Many HR staff feel uncertain at this point: do we now have to force a meeting anyway? No. Under Section 167(2) SGB IX, BEM is voluntary for the employee. A refusal is legally valid. What is not voluntary is how the employer handles that refusal correctly.
The employee's freedom ends with their refusal. The employer's obligations begin exactly there — with airtight documentation that the offer was made and the refusal was received.
Step 1: What Must the Invitation Contain for a Refusal to Count?
Before a refusal can be documented, the invitation itself must have been complete and correct. A BEM invitation must include: (1) the purpose of the meeting — explicitly: supporting the employee's return, not oversight or sanction; (2) a notice that participation is voluntary and that a refusal must not be sanctioned; (3) a notice of the right to bring a trusted person or the works council; (4) a data protection notice: what data will be stored and who has access.
A common mistake: the invitation fails to name 'Betriebliches Eingliederungsmanagement' (occupational reintegration management, BEM) explicitly, or vaguely describes it as 'a conversation about your absences.' The term BEM must be stated explicitly — otherwise the invitation is formally considered incomplete.
The invitation must be demonstrably delivered. Recommendation: registered mail with proof of delivery (Einwurf-Einschreiben) — not email (delivery is hard to prove) and not an in-person handover (requires a witness). The proof of delivery is the first document in the BEM file.
Step 2: How Long Should You Wait for a Reply — and What Then?
We recommend about 14 days — the law sets no deadline. After the invitation is delivered, the employee needs a reasonable amount of time to respond; considerably shorter deadlines restrict voluntariness and can make the invitation open to challenge.
Four possible scenarios after the deadline passes: (A) No response — the refusal is deemed accepted through silence once the deadline passes; the date the deadline expired is noted in the log. (B) Verbal refusal — witnesses to the refusal must be recorded, and written confirmation should be requested. (C) Written refusal — the letter goes directly into the BEM file. (D) Conditional acceptance — not a refusal case; the regular BEM process now begins.
Scenario A (silence) is legally the least secure. Send a brief reminder after the deadline passes, worded as: 'If we do not hear back from you by [date], we will assume that you are declining the offer.'
Step 3: What Belongs in the Refusal Record?
The BEM refusal record must include the following elements: date of the invitation, date and method of delivery (note the registered-mail tracking number), the employee's full name (no initials), date of the refusal statement or expiry of the deadline, type of refusal (written / verbal with witnesses / silence after deadline), date the record was created, HR signature.
What must not appear in the record: speculation about the reasons for the refusal, diagnoses or assumptions about illness, comments on the employee's performance. The record documents the process — not the content.
In EasyWHP, which offers BEM-Kompass free of charge, the refusal is recorded directly in the BEM case: the date of the invitation, the method of delivery and the date of the response are already there, because the procedure records them step by step. What else belongs in the record in an individual case is something to clarify with specialists. How EasyWHP guides you through BEM →
Step 4: How and for How Long Is the BEM File Kept?
The BEM file (including the refusal record) is kept separate from the regular personnel file. This follows from the GDPR (Art. 9 — special category of data).
Access to the BEM file must be restricted exclusively to the BEM team or BEM coordination — not the direct supervisor, not accounting/finance. In a digital system, the file should be maintained with an access log.
Retention period: there is no statutory period. Recommended practice: at least until the end of the employment relationship, plus the regular three-year limitation period (Section 195 BGB, German Civil Code). Longer periods, such as 5 years from the conclusion of the BEM process, should be justified in the deletion concept.
Related measures & topics
Key takeaways
- BEM is voluntary for employees — but the refusal must be documented without gaps.
- A complete, correct invitation is the prerequisite: purpose, voluntariness, data protection, right to bring a companion.
- Recommendation: about 14 days to respond before silence is treated as a refusal.
- Refusal record: filed separately, accessible only to the BEM team.
- Missing documentation means an extended burden of presentation and proof for an illness-related dismissal.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if we haven't documented a BEM refusal and then need to terminate the employee?+
That's the central risk. Without a documented refusal, BEM is treated as “never offered” — an illness-related dismissal is then not automatically invalid, but the employer bears an extended burden of presentation and proof. The Federal Labor Court (BAG) made this clear in two leading rulings (2 AZR 716/06, 2 AZR 755/13): without a proper BEM offer, the requirements for the dismissal rise so far that they are, in practice, almost impossible to meet.
Can an employee reverse their refusal?+
Yes, at any time. The refusal is not a final decision. The employee can return to a previously declined invitation and agree to take part in BEM. In that case, the regular BEM process begins. The original refusal stays on record; the new discussion is conducted as its own, separate BEM case.
Do we have to offer BEM again if the employee crosses the 6-week threshold again?+
Yes. The obligation to offer BEM arises with every new period of incapacity in which the threshold of more than six weeks of incapacity within one year is exceeded again — regardless of an earlier refusal. The earlier refusal applies only to that earlier period of incapacity.
What if the employee wants to talk after all, following the refusal — but informally?+
Encourage the conversation — but do not document it as BEM. An informal 'How are you doing?' remains an informal conversation. BEM is only formally initiated through the invitation under Section 167(2) SGB IX. Don't mix the two formats — an informal conversation cannot later be reclassified as BEM.
Manage BEM Case Handling Digitally
EasyWHP logs BEM invitations, deadlines, and refusals — clean and fully traceable.
Sources
- BAG ruling 2 AZR 755/13 (November 20, 2014) — Requirements for the BEM offer and extended burden of presentation ↗
- Section 167(2) SGB IX — Occupational Reintegration Management (Betriebliches Eingliederungsmanagement) ↗
Last updated: 2026-06-24. This guide refers to German law (§ 167 SGB IX) and is not legal advice — have your specific case reviewed by a professional.